Mickey's Not-So-Scary vs Legoland Brick or Treat: What We Paid and How to Do Either One Right (2026)

We did both Florida Halloween parties last fall with the same four people, and I still think about the receipts.

Mickey's Not-So-Scary at Magic Kingdom: $932 for one night.

Brick or Treat at Legoland Florida: $320, and that one included the entire day at the park, not just the evening.

That gap is real, but it is not the whole story, and I do not want to pretend it is. These two events are built for different kids. So here is the honest comparison, and then the game plan for whichever one you pick.

The theme parks are somehow EVEN BETTER for Halloween!

The short answer

Pick Brick or Treat if your kids are little, they fade before nine, you want a full day instead of an evening, or the budget is doing the deciding. It is the easier day and it is not close.

Pick Not-So-Scary if what you want is that sparkle in your eye kind of magic. The Headless Horseman, the parade, the Sanderson Sisters. Disney does that better than anybody. It is just a lot of money for the half of the night a little kid will actually be awake for.

What each ticket actually gets you

Brick or Treat, included with regular admission

• No separate party ticket, no upcharge wristband, no second gate

• Select nights, Sept 5 through Oct 31

• Candy stations open throughout the park from 2pm to 7pm, bags free

• The Monster Skytacular drone show, which combines drones with fireworks, plus the Zombie Cheer Crew and dance parties

• LEGO monster meet and greets

• New for 2026: Brick or Treat Street and the Potion Mischief light trail

• Free Pop Badges, one per person while they last

• The whole park, all day, before any of the Halloween stuff even starts

  
  

Not-So-Scary, its own admission ticket

• $119 to $229 per ticket plus tax, and kids pay the same as adults

• 38 party nights, Aug 7 through Oct 31

• You are in at 4pm, the party runs 7pm to midnight

• Mickey's Boo to You Halloween Parade at 8:15pm and again at 11:15pm, opened by the Headless Horseman

• Mobile food ordering, which makes getting dinner genuinely easy

• Disney's Not-So-Spooky Spectacular fireworks at 10pm

• Hocus Pocus Villain Spelltacular, multiple showings through the night

• Unlimited free candy, a treat bag on the way in, and teal tokens for allergy-friendly stations

• Around 20 attractions running, with genuinely short waits

• Adults can wear full costumes, which is a rare Magic Kingdom thing

  

  We had a ball at Mickey's Not So Scary Halloween!

  
  

One important note I want to make, because I had it wrong myself at first: the Not-So-Scary ticket is its own admission. You are not buying a day ticket on top of it. That is a common misunderstanding and it makes the price look even worse than it is.

The real difference is the clock, not the money

This is the part I wish someone had put plainly for me.

Look at when the headline stuff happens at each one.

At Not-So-Scary, the parade is 8:15pm and 11:15pm. The fireworks are 10pm. The villain show runs 9:05, 10:35 and midnight. Everything you are paying for is a night event, and the genuinely uncrowded version of it is the late showing.

At Brick or Treat, the candy trail runs 2pm to 7pm. Afternoon into early evening. The drone show closes things out, but the bulk of the Halloween experience happens while your kids are still functioning.

So the question is not really "which is better." Both are AMAZING. The question is whether your kids will still be awake for the thing you paid for.

Ours would not have been. That is the entire reason the math landed the way it did for us.

What surprised us at each one

At Legoland, it was the LEGO build stations inside the ride queues. Bins of bricks, right there in line. Your kids build while you wait and the wait stops being a wait. I have been to a lot of theme parks and I have never seen another one do this, and it is the single biggest reason Legoland is easier with little kids.

Also, and I say this with love: we spent all that money and our kids' favorite thing was a fog machine. They ran through it, screamed, went back in, and did that for what felt like twenty minutes. Plan the big stuff, but leave room for the fog machine.

I sat next to the fog machine for at least 45 minutes while they played in it. Who knew it'd be so entertaining?!

At Legoland, the other thing I was not ready for was the drone show. It is drones and fireworks together, and we had never seen that combination anywhere before. It was seriously spectacular. I went in thinking it would be the budget version of a Disney nighttime show and it absolutely was not.

• 

• 

• 

At Disney, the Headless Horseman opening the Boo to You parade was so fun and genuinely cool. And the parade itself is not just floats going by. The characters sing and dance to special Halloween music you do not hear anywhere else, and that made it feel like a real event instead of a regular parade in costumes.

The evening entertainment held up too. The Sanderson Sisters from Hocus Pocus were very well done and genuinely entertaining, not the kind of show you watch politely and then wander off from.

One practical thing: dinner

This one is worth planning around.

Disney's mobile ordering is the best thing about eating in the parks. You order from your phone, you get a window, you walk up and grab it. With kids, that convenience is worth a lot on a night when you are trying to hit a parade time.

At Legoland we struck out completely. We went looking for food during the event and everything was closed by the time we tried. I honestly cannot remember now whether that was before or after the drone show, so I do not want to state the cutoff as fact. But the lesson stands: eat earlier than you think you need to at Brick or Treat, and do not count on grabbing something late. Check current dining hours when you go, because that was the one genuinely frustrating part of an otherwise great night.

The game plan: Brick or Treat

1. Pick a September date if you can. Look at the calendar closely. September is mostly single Saturdays, while October clusters into three and four day weekends.

2. Buy tickets online, well ahead. Gate prices are dramatically higher than online prices.

3. Get there at opening and ride first, before the afternoon fills up.

4. Start the candy trail by 2pm. Those stations close at 7pm and this is the thing everyone gets wrong. If your kids are more ride people than candy people, flip it and ride during the trail hours when the lines empty out.

5. Ask every Model Citizen you pass, "do you have Mr. Gold?" Legoland hides collectible Pop Badges all over the resort, and Mr. Gold is the one only employees carry. You have to ask, over and over, all day. Hayes got one. It became our kids' whole mission and it kept them happy in every line.

6. Let them build in the ride queues. Do not rush them through it. It is the point.

7. Claim a drone show spot about 20 minutes early. Reserved stadium seating costs extra and we did fine without it.

8. Eat earlier than you think you need to. We went looking for dinner during the event and everything was already closed. Do not save it for after the show.

9. Leave room for whatever your fog machine turns out to be.

   
   

The game plan: Not-So-Scary

1. Get there at 4pm, not 7pm. You are paying for those three extra hours whether you use them or not, and the park is calmest then.

2. Grab your wristband on the way in. If you were already in the park that day, they hand them out in Tomorrowland, Fantasyland and Adventureland.

3. Ride and meet characters early. The rare costumed characters build long lines fast once the party proper starts.

4. Go to the second parade, not the first. The 11:15pm showing is much emptier. If your kids cannot make it that late, that tells you something useful about whether this is your event.

5. Save trick-or-treating for the last hour. The station lines basically disappear and you can clear several quickly.

6. Ask for teal tokens if you need allergy-friendly candy. They swap at dedicated centers.

7. Use mobile ordering for dinner. Put the order in before you are hungry, pick a window that clears you well before the 8:15 parade, and skip the line entirely.

8. Dress for 90 degrees. Adults can wear full costumes here, which is genuinely fun, but it is still Florida in September. Costume tops over regular clothes beat full polyester every time, and comfortable shoes always win.

   

   Disney is so very special, and even more magical at Halloween

Where we stayed

Art of Animation for the Disney trip. Fabulous...and expensive. The pools are AMAZING and the giant sculptures of different characters are so fun. The on-site playground was a huge hit and truly spectaculr in design. It's incredible, and you will pay real $$$ for it.

Legoland Hotel for the Brick or Treat trip. Significantly less expesnive than the Art of Animation at Disney. We loved the bunkbeds, and the playgrounds right outside the front door of the room. The pool was great with the giant legos and the food was decent.

Both of those deserve their own posts, so I am keeping it short here and will link them up as they go live.

The bottom line

Here is how I would put it to a friend.

If budget is a consideration at all, go to Brick or Treat. It really is fabulous and it gives you significantly more for your money. A full day, the Halloween event included, and a drone and fireworks show that genuinely stunned us. I would not describe it as the cheaper option. I would describe it as the better value, which is a different thing.

But if what you are after is that true sparkle in your eye kind of magic, you cannot really beat Not-So-Scary. The Headless Horseman coming down the parade route, the characters singing and dancing to music you hear nowhere else, the Sanderson Sisters. Disney does that better than anyone and it is worth knowing that going in.

So it is not really cheaper versus better. It is value versus magic, and both of those are legitimate things to want on a Halloween night with your kids.

Happy exploring!

Prices here are what we personally paid, plus what Legoland and Disney published for 2026. Both parks price by date, so check current pricing before you book.

About the Author. Hi, I'm Kate! I live on Florida's Gulf coast with my family, and Sunshine Fam Guide is where I share the trips, parks, springs and beach days we have actually done. Usually with a stroller, a cooler, and at least one meltdown. Every guide on this site comes from a trip we took ourselves. If I tell you the candy stations close at 7pm, it is because we found out the hard way. Come say hi on Instagram or YouTube